Fantasy baseball question

[jpf25]

I am in an auction keeper league that has been going for 3 years now and I've got a dilemma. I have got some huge free agents that I am probably going to sign (Manny, Lidge, Johan) and if I sign all 3 then I'll be hurting for signing the rest of my team......

Now I have a trade proposed to me that has me sending Johan to another team for Travis Hafner, Fausto Carmona, Fernando Rodney and a 1st round rookie draft pick (we have a rookie draft where we draft players with no MLB experience)

I am probably going to take the deal, but I am actually wondering if I am getting enough for Johan.....

Any thoughts?

[six24]

Here's my take for what it's worth.
I think it depends on which Fausto Carmona you think will pitch for Cleveland this year,
The 2007 19-8 137 K's 3.06 ERA or the 2006/2008 11-7 5.43 ERA

With Rodney being handed the closer job in Detroit He might get a few more saves but he again might be a 1 hit wonder 4.91 ERA 0-6 in 13 saves and 6 blown saves for a medicore Tigers teams. Believe me as a Tiger fan I cringed EVERY time they brought him into the game (Todd Jones too)

If Hafener comes back healthy this year will put up solid #'s as a DH

This being said you are being offered 3 players all coming off of injuries the last season.